top of page

FA Cup farce! Liverpool overwhelm Villa youngsters in match that should have never happened

The Premier League champions saw off a side of U23 and U18 players in an ill-fated cup tie on Friday

Different season, different competition, different context.

Same teams, same feeling.

An absolute farce.

This, quite frankly, was a game that should never have been played. A game between the Premier League leaders, the reigning champions, and a group of teenagers, pressed into action on primetime TV just so, despite everything, the show could somehow go on.

When all was said and done here, Liverpool were into the FA Cup fourth round. Safely through, despite a minor scare, after beating an Aston Villa side made up entirely of academy players, and managed by their U23s coach.

The Reds’ 4-1 victory may have ended a three-match winless run, but if this is ‘elite’ football in 2021, then questions must be asked. We learned nothing from this, except that Villa have some kids with some balls. Good on them.

Nobody from Anfield was celebrating at the final whistle, and you could understand why. So much for the magic of the cup.

“I am not going to pretend that this is a good news event,” said Christian Purslow, Villa’s chief executive - and that was before kick-off.

An outbreak of coronavirus meant Villa attacked the so-called ‘greatest cup competition in the world’ without any of their senior squad, manager Dean Smith or his first-team coaching staff.

In their place were a mix of U23 and U18 players, none of whom had previously featured in a senior squad. Most of them had, according to Purslow, “been dropped off by their parents” for the game. One, defender Jake Walker, had been recalled from a loan spell with Alvechurch, of the Southern League Premier Central, on Friday morning.

Fantastic for those kids, of course. And what an account they gave of themselves against some of the world’s best players. Mark Delaney’s side were level just before half-time, picking themselves up after conceding inside the first four minutes. They were overwhelmed after that, but they can be proud of their efforts. They were brilliant.

Jurgen Klopp had made few concessions despite the callow nature of his opponents. Liverpool fielded the likes of Mohamed Salah, Sadio Mane, Jordan Henderson and Fabinho in their starting XI and brought Thiago Alcantara and Roberto Firmino, among others, off a star-studded bench. "We prepared for Villa's first team," Klopp said afterwards.

The result, of course, was never in doubt, even after Louie Barry had levelled for the home side before half-time. Liverpool had checked on the 17-year-old, who came through West Brom’s academy, a year ago when he was leaving Barcelona, and they will certainly have been impressed at how calmly he converted his first chance of the evening, having run behind Rhys Williams to reach Callum Rowe’s through-ball. He looks a player, and his post-match interview was probably the best thing about the entire evening.

At 1-1 there was the prospect, albeit faint, of one of the great all-time cup shocks, but Liverpool were always going to overpower their hosts after the interval, and three goals in five second-half minutes did the trick. Gini Wijnaldum made it 2-1, Sadio Mane netted his second header of the night and Mohamed Salah got in on the act.

On they go, then, but what damage is being done to the sport itself right now, as it ploughs on – or attempts to – despite everything happening in the world right now?

Villa’s next league game, against Tottenham on Wednesday, looks certain to be postponed. More will follow, surely, as Covid cases continue to rise across the Premier League. They announced 40 positive tests this week, and there will be more for sure - even if the Premier League has vowed to "get tough" with clubs with a series of new guidelines, including suggestions to limit high-fives and goal celebrations.

As if that will make a difference. Even the managers are starting to understand we might be reaching a breaking point, that the sport may need to pause, just as the rest of the world has to.

“Financially it's right to play on,” said Newcastle boss Steve Bruce this week. “But for me, morally, it's probably wrong.”

West Brom’s Sam Allardyce has called for a 'circuit-breaker' for the league, while Tottenham’s Jose Mourinho believes further postponements will make it “impossible” for his side to complete their already-crowded fixture schedule.

An increasing number of players, meanwhile, believe they are being treated as guinea pigs, forced to play and to risk their own health as well as that of their families. And that's before we talk about the injuries and the fatigue, both physical and mental. They might be well paid, but money doesn't protect you from everything.

Speaking of money, clubs are losing it just by virtue of having to play games, while the integrity of each competition is being compromised on an almost daily basis.

It certainly was here, and it will be again on Saturday, when Derby County will be forced to play Chorley with a team of academy players. They have 14 available youth-teamers, see, so they'll have to play.

Others have been less fortunate. Southampton’s tie against Shrewsbury has already been called off, while the Women’s Super League schedule has been decimated.

In the EFL, 112 positive Covid-19 tests were recorded across 66 clubs, meaning postponements are inevitable. Some clubs are already well behind in terms of games played. Further down the ladder, proposals have been made to scrap the season entirely.

Nobody is suggesting the same should happen at the highest level, of course, but it is clear that something will have to give in the coming weeks. English football’s determination to crack on as if everything is fine, playing both domestic cup competitions as normal, cramming in league fixtures and asking clubs and players to deal with the fallout, simply cannot go on.

We know why the Premier League rolls on. The financial implications are too big. But if anyone can explain why the FA Cup or the Carabao Cup are being played then please step forward. They shouldn't be. They don't need to be.

This is a romantic competition, a traditionalist's dream, but there was nothing romantic or traditional about this tonight. It was men against boys, and guess what? The men won.

As James Milner said: "Nobody wants this, but it's where we're at."

The Magic of the Cup, indeed.

Register account with us at

Get 5% weekly rebate and more exclusive promotion now!

浏览 并与我们注册账号,


1 view0 comments


bottom of page